ShopSubscribeThe JournalWall of LoveAbout
Naturally Better

Grapefruit: The Forbidden Fruit

The youngest of the great citrus is an eighteenth-century accident — a chance child of the ancient pomelo, born in a Barbados garden and christened the forbidden fruit. Read two ways: through the thousand-year-old parent that lends it gravity, and through the modern laboratory that gave it the most famous footnote any fruit can claim.

Lalaland Editorial7 min read
Whole and halved pink grapefruit on warm pale stone in low golden light, coral flesh beaded with juice.
Lalaland Juice

Halve a pink grapefruit and the scent arrives before the knife is through — sharp, faintly floral, with a bitterness underneath that no orange carries. The flesh is the colour of a held breath: rose at the rind, deepening to coral at the core, each segment beaded with juice. You taste it and something in you sits up. This is not a fruit that flatters. It is sour and bitter and sweet at once — the grown-up citrus, the one that asks a little more of you.

For all that composure, the grapefruit is an infant. Almost everything in the market carries a long human pedigree; this one does not. It is the youngest of the great citrus, an eighteenth-century accident — the chance child of two older fruits that met, unplanned, in a garden in Barbados. Its depth is entirely inherited. Read it two ways, and both are worth the time: through the thousand-year-old parent that lends it gravity, and through the modern laboratory that handed it the single most famous footnote any fruit can claim.

The youngest fruit in the room

Grapefruit (Citrus × paradisi) is a natural hybrid — a spontaneous cross between the pomelo (Citrus maxima) and the sweet orange, both of them Asian fruits carried to the Caribbean in the seventeenth century.[2][3] Neither parent is native to the New World; both were established in the West Indies by 1692, and somewhere among the warm gardens of Barbados they crossed on their own, without a gardener's hand.[2] The result was a fruit nobody had planned and nobody had seen: larger than an orange, bitter where its parents were sweet, hanging in heavy clusters. Everything cultured and ancient about grapefruit, it borrowed. In the long calendar of the things we eat, it was born yesterday.

A garden in Barbados, and a forbidden fruit

The story begins with the parent, arriving by an old sailor's route. According to Sir Hans Sloane's A Voyage to Jamaica (1707), a Captain Shaddock — an English commander trading out of the East Indies — left the seeds of the great Asian pomelo in Barbados as he passed through.[4] The seeds took. Across the English-speaking Caribbean the pomelo is called the shaddock to this day.[4]

Scene: a 17th-century English sea captain leaving great Asian pomelo seeds in a Barbados garden — the ancient parent of the grapefruit arrives in the New World.
Scene: a 17th-century English sea captain leaving great Asian pomelo seeds in a Barbados garden — the ancient parent of the grapefruit arrives in the New World.
The pomelo reaches Barbados: a sea captain leaves the seeds of the great Asian citrus. History illustration for Lalaland Editorial.

Somewhere among those transplanted trees, a pomelo and a sweet orange crossed, and the grapefruit appeared — unbidden, in a planter's garden. The first person to write it down was a Welsh clergyman. The Reverend Griffith Hughes, rector of St Lucy's parish, spent his Barbados years cataloguing the island, and in The Natural History of Barbados (1750) he described a strange new citrus he called the forbidden fruit — a tree whose fruit, he wrote, exceeded "in the Delicacy of its Taste, the Fruit of every Tree in this or any of our neighbouring Islands."[1] It is the earliest known description of grapefruit anywhere.[1]

Scene: the Reverend Griffith Hughes sketching and naming the 'forbidden fruit' tree in Barbados, 1750 — the first record of the grapefruit.
Scene: the Reverend Griffith Hughes sketching and naming the 'forbidden fruit' tree in Barbados, 1750 — the first record of the grapefruit.
1750: a Welsh clergyman-naturalist records the 'forbidden fruit'. History illustration for Lalaland Editorial.

The friendlier name came later, and by accident too. In 1814 the Jamaican naturalist John Lunan printed the word grapefruit, remarking that the fruit hung in tight clusters, like an enormous bunch of grapes.[5] The name that stuck is a small botanical joke — a citrus the size of a fist, named for a grape.[5][2]

The ancient parent

Grapefruit has no old text of its own; it arrived too late for one. Its parent, though, is written deep into the record — and lends the young fruit its only real claim on antiquity. The pomelo — 柚 (yòu) in Chinese — has been prized in the East for well over a thousand years.

When Li Shizhen completed the Compendium of Materia Medica (本草綱目) in 1578 — the towering Ming pharmacopoeia, three decades in the making — he gave the pomelo its own entry among the fruits. He set it down as sour and cooling (酸, 寒), harmless, a fruit that "disperses food, resolves the toxin of wine, and clears foul qi from the stomach and gut" (消食, 解酒毒).[6] Five centuries before anyone had heard of an enzyme, the physician had read the citrus exactly right: a bitter, cooling thing that cuts through richness and settles a heavy table. Anyone who has reached for grapefruit after a long dinner knows precisely what he meant.

The pomelo at the full moon

In Singapore the pomelo's oldest meaning comes round each autumn. At the Mid-Autumn Festival, when the mooncakes are cut, a whole pomelo sits on the table — because 柚 (yòu) sounds like 佑, to bless and protect, and like 有, to have.[7] To eat pomelo under the full moon is to ask, in a pun a thousand years old, for blessing and abundance. Children wear the emptied rind as a hat — a small helmet of citrus — in the hope the moon will notice and grant the wish.[7]

Scene: a Chinese Mid-Autumn Festival — a whole pomelo on the offering table and a child wearing a pomelo-rind hat under the full moon.
Scene: a Chinese Mid-Autumn Festival — a whole pomelo on the offering table and a child wearing a pomelo-rind hat under the full moon.
Mid-Autumn: the pomelo as blessing, and a child in a pomelo-rind hat. History illustration for Lalaland Editorial.

This is the lineage the grapefruit married into: a festival fruit, an offering, a thing set on the table to be honoured. The pink infant in the Barbados garden inherited all that gravity without ever having to earn it.

The reading modern medicine takes seriously

Here grapefruit steps out of its parent's shadow and does something no other fruit has managed — it earned a permanent place in the pharmacology textbook.

In 1989 a team in Ontario, led by the pharmacologist David Bailey, was testing a blood-pressure drug and used grapefruit juice to mask the taste of alcohol in the trial. The alcohol did nothing. The grapefruit did something startling: blood levels of the drug came back three times higher than the dose should have allowed.[8] Their report in The Lancet in 1991 opened with the admission that it was "a chance finding."[8]

The cause is a family of compounds called furanocoumarins, all but unique to grapefruit and its pomelo parent. They switch off an enzyme in the wall of the gut — CYP3A4 — whose task is to break certain medicines down before they reach the blood.[10][9] Disable it, and the body absorbs far more of a drug than the dose intends. The effect is not fleeting: the gut must rebuild the enzyme from scratch, so a single glass can matter for the better part of a day.[10] More than eighty-five medicines are now known to interact with grapefruit, and over forty of them can do serious harm.[9] It is the one fruit a pharmacist may ask you about by name — a genuine, grown-up footnote worth knowing if you take daily medication, and nothing to fear if you do not.

What it actually gives, honestly

Strip away the mythology and the fruit is still remarkable — just not in the way the twentieth century wished it to be. For decades grapefruit was sold as a slimming miracle, the sour centrepiece of the mid-century "grapefruit diet," as though the bitterness itself could melt away weight. It cannot, and never could. That is the fad we leave behind. The real fruit is the more interesting one.

Half a grapefruit carries roughly half a day's vitamin C.[12] Its bitterness is naringin, a flavonoid — the grown-up edge that no breeding has ever bred out, and the very thing a sweetened drink is designed to hide.[2] And the pink is lycopene, the same pigment that reddens tomatoes and watermelon; the deeper the flesh, the more of it, which is why the ruby varieties glow.[11] That colour is itself a young accident — the Ruby Red was found in 1929 as a single mutated branch on a tree in the Rio Grande Valley of Texas, and every pink grapefruit since descends from bud-sports like it.[11] A fruit all of two centuries old, still improvising.

Where this leaves the fruit

Grapefruit is not a superfood, and never asked to be. It is the youngest of the citrus — an accident with an ancient parent, bittersweet and faintly bitter, honest about exactly what it is. It carries a real pharmacological footnote most fruits would envy, a thousand-year Chinese pedigree it married into, and the double joke of a colour named for a pigment and a fruit named for a grape.

That contradiction is the whole pleasure of it. It is the citrus at the heart of our own blush-pink pour, Pink Haze — grapefruit pressed cold with pear, sour and sweet at once, the bitterness left honestly in. The forbidden fruit, on your table at last — and a good reason to slow down on a Sunday and look, for a moment, at the colour of it before you drink.

Common questions

Is grapefruit an ancient fruit?
No; it is one of the youngest fruits we eat. It appeared in Barbados only in the eighteenth century, as a natural cross between the pomelo and the sweet orange, and was first written up in 1750. Its ancient lineage runs entirely through its parent, the pomelo, which was prized in China for over a thousand years.
Why is grapefruit called "the forbidden fruit"?
Because that was its first name. When the Reverend Griffith Hughes described it in Barbados in 1750, he called it the forbidden fruit. The name "grapefruit", for the grape-like clusters in which it grows, came later, in 1814, from the Jamaican naturalist John Lunan.
Is the grapefruit–medication interaction real, and should I worry?
It is entirely real and well documented. Furanocoumarins in grapefruit disable a gut enzyme, CYP3A4, that breaks down many medicines, so the body can absorb more of a drug than intended; more than eighty-five medicines are affected, over forty of them seriously. If you take regular medication, ask your doctor or pharmacist. If you don't, it is simply one of the most fascinating facts in pharmacology.
Why is pink grapefruit pink?
The pink comes from lycopene, with some beta-carotene — the same pigments that colour tomatoes and watermelon. The deeper the flesh, the more of it; the ruby varieties all descend from a single mutated branch found on a Texas tree in 1929.
Does grapefruit help you lose weight?
No. The "grapefruit diet" was a twentieth-century fad, not science. Grapefruit is worth eating for what it genuinely is — a bittersweet, vitamin-C-rich citrus with a real pharmacological story — not as a weight-loss trick.
Which Lalaland juice is made with grapefruit?
Pink Haze: the blush-pink one, grapefruit pressed cold with pear, bittersweet and grown-up. It is a five-in-the-evening pleasure more than anything — sober but social, cold, rose-coloured, with the bitterness left honestly in.

Sources

  1. 1.The Natural History of Barbados, In Ten BooksEarly Caribbean Digital Archive (Northeastern University) (1750)
  2. 2.GrapefruitWikipedia
  3. 3.Mystery of the forbidden fruit: Historical epilogue on the origin of the grapefruit, Citrus paradisi (Rutaceae)Economic Botany (Springer) (1987)
  4. 4.ShaddockOxford Reference
  5. 5.GrapefruitWorld Wide Words
  6. 6.本草綱目 · 果部 · 柚 (Compendium of Materia Medica, Fruit Section, Pomelo)Gushiji (1578)
  7. 7.Why Are Pomelo Fruits Eaten During Moon Festival?Asian Inspirations
  8. 8.David Bailey, Olympian and pharmacologist who discovered the grapefruit effect, dead at age 77The Globe and Mail
  9. 9.Grapefruit–medication interactions: Forbidden fruit or avoidable consequences?Canadian Medical Association Journal (CMAJ) (2013)
  10. 10.The Grapefruit-Drug InteractionMcGill University Office for Science and Society
  11. 11.The Origins of Red Pigmented Grapefruits and the Development of New VarietiesResearchGate / Acta Horticulturae
  12. 12.Grapefruit Nutrition FactsFlorida Department of Citrus

Keep reading